Compare Recycled Materials

Environmental, Social and Governance Issues Associated With Sourcing Materials

Material Insights uses a proprietary approach to rate the importance of supply chain ESG issues for downstream users of materials based on information contained in publicly available reports.

Each material is assigned a score to measure the strength of association with different environmental, social, governance, or occupational health and safety issues. The material’s strength of association with each issue is categorised on a scale ranging from very low to very high, according to the severity and credibility of identified reports. 

This data can be used by downstream users to help identify issues that require further investigation, in accordance with the risk-based due diligence approach recommended by the OECD.

As of October 2025, the risk categories featured on recycled material profiles are already aligned with RMI’s standards. In contrast, the raw material profiles currently differ slightly, but are moving toward full alignment. In 2026, the ESG categories for raw materials will be fully harmonized with those used for recycled materials.

  1. Very low

  2. Low

  3. Moderate

  4. High

  5. Very High

  Social   OHS   Governance   Environmental
  Support to Armed Groups Icon
down arrow
Support to Armed Groups Icon

Support to Armed Groups

Procuring minerals from or providing payment or logistical assistance to armed groups or affiliates that illegally control or extort money or minerals at mine sites, along transportation routes, or at trading hubs. Armed groups may benefit from illegally controlling mine access, overseeing extraction, extorting intermediaries, or holding beneficial or other ownership interests in upstream companies or mines.

Land Acquisition and Resettlement Icon
down arrow
Land Acquisition and Resettlement Icon

Land Acquisition and Resettlement

Land acquisition and resettlement risk is the threat to the well-being, dignity, and livelihoods of people who are displaced from their homes, land, or sources of income due to development projects, often without adequate compensation, consultation, or support.

Cultural Heritage Icon
down arrow
Cultural Heritage Icon

Cultural Heritage

Respect of customs, practices, places, objects, artistic expressions and values. Respect the right of a group to be able to express and maintain their traditions or practices, including the right to access and enjoy cultural heritage.

Rights of Indigenous Peoples Icon
down arrow
Rights of Indigenous Peoples Icon

Rights of Indigenous Peoples

Indigenous Peoples’ rights refer to the collective and individual rights held by Indigenous peoples—those who are the original inhabitants of a particular region or territory—based on their unique historical, cultural, social, and political circumstances. Core aspects of Indigenous Peoples’ rights include self-determination, land, territory and resources, cultural rights, participation and consultation, non-discrimination and equality, protection from assimilation and destruction.

Community Health, Safety, and Development Icon
down arrow
Community Health, Safety, and Development Icon

Community Health, Safety, and Development

Respect communities’ right to safe and healthy living conditions, and prohibit the arbitrary or unlawful interference with a person’s privacy, family, home or correspondence and unlawful attacks on their reputation.

Employment Terms Icon
down arrow
Employment Terms Icon

Employment Terms

Workers’ rights to fair and decent employment terms, including entitlement to work, hiring, remuneration, and working hours. This category includes discrimination and harassment and risks to diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI).

Freedom of Association and Collective Bargaining Icon
down arrow
Freedom of Association and Collective Bargaining Icon

Freedom of Association and Collective Bargaining

Freedom of association implies respect for the right of employers and workers to freely and voluntarily establish and join organizations of their own choice, free from outside interference or monitoring.

Use of Public or Private Security Forces Icon
down arrow
Use of Public or Private Security Forces Icon

Use of Public or Private Security Forces

Public or private security forces contracted in the supply chain may be associated with serious human rights abuses, in their interactions with vulnerable groups, local communities, human rights defenders and local labour leaders, for instance due to use of excessive force, and/or use of inappropriate force on protected populations.

Forced Labor and Human Trafficking Icon
down arrow
Forced Labor and Human Trafficking Icon

Forced Labor and Human Trafficking

Forced labor can be understood as work that is performed involuntarily and under the menace of any penalty. It refers to situations in which persons are coerced to work through the use of violence or intimidation, or by more subtle means such as manipulated debt, retention of identity papers or threats of denunciation to immigration authorities. Forced labor includes bonded labor or indentured labor, involuntary or exploitative prison labor, slavery or trafficking of persons.

Child labor Icon
down arrow
Child labor Icon

Child labor

Child labor is any paid or unpaid work that is undertaken by a person under the age of 15, or the age for completing compulsory education, or the legal minimum age for employment in the country, whichever age is greatest. Further, any work that endangers a person under the age of 18 is considered hazardous child labor. Worst forms of child labour include slavery, child prostitution, use of children in criminal activities, and dangerous labour.

Serious human rights abuses Icon
down arrow
Serious human rights abuses Icon

Serious human rights abuses

Serious human rights abuses include all forms of torture or cruel, inhuman, or degrading treatment (e.g. beatings, threats, or rape). Other gross human rights violations and abuses include widespread sexual violence, war crimes, or other serious violations of international humanitarian law, crimes against humanity (e.g. mass executions, deportations, or the use of child soldiers), or genocide.

  Occupational Health and Safety Icon
down arrow
Occupational Health and Safety Icon

Occupational Health and Safety

Occupational health and safety incidents and risks.

  Money Laundering Icon
down arrow
Money Laundering Icon

Money Laundering

Money laundering is the process by which criminals disguise the illegal origin of the proceeds of criminal conduct by making such proceeds appear to have derived from a legitimate source. Money laundering in the mineral supply chain occurs when minerals purchased using the proceeds of crime are then reintroduced into the market. It also occurs when minerals are used as an alternative currency in illicit transactions, such as purchases of weapons or drugs. Trade-based money laundering involves techniques like over- and under-invoicing, phantom shipping, and multiple invoicing.

Legal Compliance Icon
down arrow
Legal Compliance Icon

Legal Compliance

Non-compliance with legal obligations (permitting, licensing, etc); fines and convictions.

Legal and Transparent Tax Paying Icon
down arrow
Legal and Transparent Tax Paying Icon

Legal and Transparent Tax Paying

Violations of law and regulations applicable to the business, non-payment of other fees and royalties due to the government.

Business Ethics Icon
down arrow
Business Ethics Icon

Business Ethics

Bribery, corruption, anti-competitive behavior and fraud.

  Tailings breaches Icon
down arrow
Tailings breaches Icon

Tailings breaches

The potential environmental, social, financial, and operational hazards associated with the storage and handling of tailings—residual materials left after the extraction of valuable minerals from ore. Mismanagement can lead to catastrophic consequences, including tailings dam failures, environmental contamination, and loss of life.

Threat to water balance Icon
down arrow
Threat to water balance Icon

Threat to water balance

Impacts on quality of water, water availability for human consumption and other economic activities, over-consumption and inefficient water use.

Physical Instability, Soil Erosion and Land Degradation Icon
down arrow
Physical Instability, Soil Erosion and Land Degradation Icon

Physical Instability, Soil Erosion and Land Degradation

Physical instability refers to the structural failure or movement of landforms and man-made structures, such as pit walls, tailings dams, waste rock dumps, or slopes, due to excavation, blasting, or natural forces. Soil erosion is the removal of topsoil by wind, water, or human activity, accelerated by the disturbance of land during exploration, excavation, and waste disposal. Land degradation is the long-term decline in the quality, productivity, and ecological function of land due to mining activities, such as deforestation, soil contamination, and habitat destruction.

Pollution Icon
down arrow
Pollution Icon

Pollution

Release of pollutants in air, soil, land, water. Generation of unwanted or excessive sounds that have harmful effects on people and environment. This category includes environmental emergencies and spill response

Greenhouse Gas Emissions, Energy and Climate Action Icon
down arrow
Greenhouse Gas Emissions, Energy and Climate Action Icon

Greenhouse Gas Emissions, Energy and Climate Action

Absence of climate actions, use of energy sources, and production of emissions that contribute to climate change.

Deforestation and Forest Degradation Icon
down arrow
Deforestation and Forest Degradation Icon

Deforestation and Forest Degradation

Deforestation and forest degradation.

Biodiversity, Protected Areas, & Productive Land Icon
down arrow
Biodiversity, Protected Areas, & Productive Land Icon

Biodiversity, Protected Areas, & Productive Land

Loss of biodiversity or critical habitat, exploration or development of new projects in World Heritage Sites or in designated protected areas and their buffer zones.

Mismanagement of hazardous substances Icon
down arrow
Mismanagement of hazardous substances Icon

Mismanagement of hazardous substances

Aluminium Very low Very low Very low Very low Very high Moderate Low Very low High High Moderate   Very high   Low High Moderate Moderate   Very low Very low Very high Very high Very low Low High Very high
Cobalt Very low Very low Very low Very low Moderate Very low Very low Very low Very low Very low Very low   Moderate   Very low Very low Very low Very low   Very low Very low Low High Very low Very low Low Low
Copper Very low Very low Very low Very low Very high Moderate Very low Very low Very low High Very low   Very high   Low Low Low Moderate   Very low Very low High Very high Very low Very low High Very high
Gold Moderate Very low Very low Very low Very high Moderate Very low Low Very low Moderate Very low   Very high   High Moderate Moderate Very high   Very low Very low High Very high Very low Very low High Very high
Iron Very low Very low Very low Very low High Low Low Very low Very low Low Low   High   Very low Moderate Low Moderate   Very low Very low Moderate High Very low Low Moderate High
Lithium Very low Very low Very low Very low Moderate Very low Very low Very low Very low Very low Very low   Moderate   Very low Very low Very low Very low   Very low Very low Low High Very low Very low Low Low
Nickel Very low Very low Very low Very low Moderate Very low Very low Very low Very low Very low Very low   Moderate   Very low Very low Very low Very low   Very low Very low Low High Very low Very low Low Low
REE Low Low Very low Very low Very high Moderate Very low Very low Very low Moderate Very low   Very low   Very high Low Low Moderate   Very low Very low Very low Low Very low Very low High Very high
Silicon Very low Very low Very low Very low Very low Very low Very low Very low Very low Very low Very low   Low   Very low Very low Very low Very low   Very low Very low Low Moderate Very low Very low Very low Moderate
Steel Very low Very low Very low Very low High Low Low Very low Very low Low Low   High   Very low Moderate Low Moderate   Very low Very low Moderate High Very low Low Moderate High
Tantalum Very low Very low Very low Very low Low Very low Very low Very low Very low Low Very low   Low   Very low Very low Very low Very low   Very low Very low Very low Very low Very low Very low Very low Very low
Tin Very low Very low Very low Very low Very high Moderate Very low Very low Very low High Very low   Very high   Low Low Low Moderate   Very low Very low High Very high Very low Very low Moderate Very high
Titanium Very low Very low Very low Very low Low Very low Very low Very low Very low Low Very low   Low   Very low Very low Very low Very low   Very low Very low Very low Very low Very low Very low Very low Very low
Tungsten Very low Very low Very low Very low Low Very low Very low Very low Very low Very low Very low   Low   Very low Very low Very low Very low   Very low Very low Low Low Very low Very low Low Very low
Zinc Very low Very low Very low Very low Moderate Low Low Very low Very low Low Low   High   Very low Moderate Low Moderate   Very low Very low Moderate Moderate Very low Low Low High
remove cross

Social

Support to Armed Groups Icon

Support to Armed Groups

toggle arrow

Procuring minerals from or providing payment or logistical assistance to armed groups or affiliates that illegally control or extort money or minerals at mine sites, along transportation routes, or at trading hubs. Armed groups may benefit from illegally controlling mine access, overseeing extraction, extorting intermediaries, or holding beneficial or other ownership interests in upstream companies or mines.

Land Acquisition and Resettlement Icon

Land Acquisition and Resettlement

toggle arrow

Land acquisition and resettlement risk is the threat to the well-being, dignity, and livelihoods of people who are displaced from their homes, land, or sources of income due to development projects, often without adequate compensation, consultation, or support.

Cultural Heritage Icon

Cultural Heritage

toggle arrow

Respect of customs, practices, places, objects, artistic expressions and values. Respect the right of a group to be able to express and maintain their traditions or practices, including the right to access and enjoy cultural heritage.

Rights of Indigenous Peoples Icon

Rights of Indigenous Peoples

toggle arrow

Indigenous Peoples’ rights refer to the collective and individual rights held by Indigenous peoples—those who are the original inhabitants of a particular region or territory—based on their unique historical, cultural, social, and political circumstances. Core aspects of Indigenous Peoples’ rights include self-determination, land, territory and resources, cultural rights, participation and consultation, non-discrimination and equality, protection from assimilation and destruction.

Community Health, Safety, and Development Icon

Community Health, Safety, and Development

toggle arrow

Respect communities’ right to safe and healthy living conditions, and prohibit the arbitrary or unlawful interference with a person’s privacy, family, home or correspondence and unlawful attacks on their reputation.

Employment Terms Icon

Employment Terms

toggle arrow

Workers’ rights to fair and decent employment terms, including entitlement to work, hiring, remuneration, and working hours. This category includes discrimination and harassment and risks to diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI).

Freedom of Association and Collective Bargaining Icon

Freedom of Association and Collective Bargaining

toggle arrow

Freedom of association implies respect for the right of employers and workers to freely and voluntarily establish and join organizations of their own choice, free from outside interference or monitoring.

Use of Public or Private Security Forces Icon

Use of Public or Private Security Forces

toggle arrow

Public or private security forces contracted in the supply chain may be associated with serious human rights abuses, in their interactions with vulnerable groups, local communities, human rights defenders and local labour leaders, for instance due to use of excessive force, and/or use of inappropriate force on protected populations.

Forced Labor and Human Trafficking Icon

Forced Labor and Human Trafficking

toggle arrow

Forced labor can be understood as work that is performed involuntarily and under the menace of any penalty. It refers to situations in which persons are coerced to work through the use of violence or intimidation, or by more subtle means such as manipulated debt, retention of identity papers or threats of denunciation to immigration authorities. Forced labor includes bonded labor or indentured labor, involuntary or exploitative prison labor, slavery or trafficking of persons.

Child labor Icon

Child labor

toggle arrow

Child labor is any paid or unpaid work that is undertaken by a person under the age of 15, or the age for completing compulsory education, or the legal minimum age for employment in the country, whichever age is greatest. Further, any work that endangers a person under the age of 18 is considered hazardous child labor. Worst forms of child labour include slavery, child prostitution, use of children in criminal activities, and dangerous labour.

Serious human rights abuses Icon

Serious human rights abuses

toggle arrow

Serious human rights abuses include all forms of torture or cruel, inhuman, or degrading treatment (e.g. beatings, threats, or rape). Other gross human rights violations and abuses include widespread sexual violence, war crimes, or other serious violations of international humanitarian law, crimes against humanity (e.g. mass executions, deportations, or the use of child soldiers), or genocide.

OHS

Occupational Health and Safety Icon

Occupational Health and Safety

toggle arrow

Occupational health and safety incidents and risks.

Governance

Money Laundering Icon

Money Laundering

toggle arrow

Money laundering is the process by which criminals disguise the illegal origin of the proceeds of criminal conduct by making such proceeds appear to have derived from a legitimate source. Money laundering in the mineral supply chain occurs when minerals purchased using the proceeds of crime are then reintroduced into the market. It also occurs when minerals are used as an alternative currency in illicit transactions, such as purchases of weapons or drugs. Trade-based money laundering involves techniques like over- and under-invoicing, phantom shipping, and multiple invoicing.

Legal Compliance Icon

Legal Compliance

toggle arrow

Non-compliance with legal obligations (permitting, licensing, etc); fines and convictions.

Legal and Transparent Tax Paying Icon

Legal and Transparent Tax Paying

toggle arrow

Violations of law and regulations applicable to the business, non-payment of other fees and royalties due to the government.

Business Ethics Icon

Business Ethics

toggle arrow

Bribery, corruption, anti-competitive behavior and fraud.

Environmental

Tailings breaches Icon

Tailings breaches

toggle arrow

The potential environmental, social, financial, and operational hazards associated with the storage and handling of tailings—residual materials left after the extraction of valuable minerals from ore. Mismanagement can lead to catastrophic consequences, including tailings dam failures, environmental contamination, and loss of life.

Threat to water balance Icon

Threat to water balance

toggle arrow

Impacts on quality of water, water availability for human consumption and other economic activities, over-consumption and inefficient water use.

Physical Instability, Soil Erosion and Land Degradation Icon

Physical Instability, Soil Erosion and Land Degradation

toggle arrow

Physical instability refers to the structural failure or movement of landforms and man-made structures, such as pit walls, tailings dams, waste rock dumps, or slopes, due to excavation, blasting, or natural forces. Soil erosion is the removal of topsoil by wind, water, or human activity, accelerated by the disturbance of land during exploration, excavation, and waste disposal. Land degradation is the long-term decline in the quality, productivity, and ecological function of land due to mining activities, such as deforestation, soil contamination, and habitat destruction.

Pollution Icon

Pollution

toggle arrow

Release of pollutants in air, soil, land, water. Generation of unwanted or excessive sounds that have harmful effects on people and environment. This category includes environmental emergencies and spill response

Greenhouse Gas Emissions, Energy and Climate Action Icon

Greenhouse Gas Emissions, Energy and Climate Action

toggle arrow

Absence of climate actions, use of energy sources, and production of emissions that contribute to climate change.

Deforestation and Forest Degradation Icon

Deforestation and Forest Degradation

toggle arrow

Deforestation and forest degradation.

Biodiversity, Protected Areas, & Productive Land Icon

Biodiversity, Protected Areas, & Productive Land

toggle arrow

Loss of biodiversity or critical habitat, exploration or development of new projects in World Heritage Sites or in designated protected areas and their buffer zones.

Mismanagement of hazardous substances Icon

Mismanagement of hazardous substances

toggle arrow